How to choose tax practice management software for a small tax firm
Choose tax practice software by running one real return through it before the season starts. Feature lists look alike in October; the differences show when a client photographs a W-2 in February. For the products side by side, see the tax practice software table.
Which features matter most in tax practice software?
Five features matter most in a tax season: organizers, document collection, reading of tax forms, return status, and the client’s approval.
| Feature | What to check | In Firmary |
|---|---|---|
| Organizers | One per return, visible to the client | An organizer on the engagements that use one |
| Document collection | Phone uploads and reusable checklists | PocketFirm uploads and photos; request templates |
| Reading tax forms | Values proposed, a person confirming | Read for the preparer to confirm: W-2, 1098, 1099-INT, -DIV and -B, composite 1099 statements and the Form 1065 Schedule K-1 |
| Return status | Firm stages, review, e-file status | Firm’s own stages, review notes, e-file status the client sees |
| Client approval | Draft approved before filing | Approval in PocketFirm |
How do you test tax practice software before the season?
Run one real return through it from start to finish, with a real client on a phone:
- Send the engagement letter and have both spouses sign.
- Send the organizer and have the client photograph a W-2.
- Check what the software read from the W-2, and what it asked a person to confirm.
- Send the draft for approval, then record the e-file status.
- Ask the client what they saw at each step.
In Firmary each step happens on the same client record. Clients see their outstanding requests and the e-file status staff record.
How do you cut down client status calls in tax season?
Show clients where their return stands before they ask. In Firmary, a client signed in to PocketFirm sees the work the firm has open for them, how far along it is and what they still have to do, and the e-file status appears once staff record it. Following a request link and typing its one-time code opens only that request.
On the firm’s side, staff see when a client has read the latest message, and the Needs reply view keeps any thread where the client wrote last from going unanswered.
What does tax practice management software cost per season?
Add the subscription to the per-use charges a season will run up. On 10 Nov 2026, Liscio charged $7 for each organizer or tax delivery sent without a bundle,1 and TaxDome charged $15 down to $5 for each active client beyond the first 150, depending on volume.2 Soraban published no price.3
Ask each vendor for a season quote using last year’s return count and client count.
When should a tax firm switch practice management software?
Switch between seasons, so there is time to check the imported data before clients are involved. From TaxDome, other practice software or spreadsheets, Firmary stages the clients, contacts, jobs, recurring work, invoices, time and documents it can read for the firm to check before importing; what moves depends on the source, and client messages stay behind. No client is contacted, the old tool keeps running until the firm switches, and someone from Firmary’s team can take on the move with you. Answers on timing and cost cover the rest.
Questions to ask in a demo
- Send me an engagement letter for a joint return. Can both of us sign it?
- Show me the organizer as the client sees it on a phone.
- I’ll photograph a W-2. What does the software read from it, and what do I confirm?
- Where does a 1099 go when the client sends it without being asked?
- How does a return move through our stages, and what can happen automatically?
- Where does the reviewer leave notes, and how does the preparer answer them?
- Send me the draft for approval. What do I see, and what happens when I approve?
- Record an e-file rejection. What does the client see?
- What happens to a preparer’s clients when they are out sick in March?
- Which per-use charges will we hit in a season?
- Can we move between seasons and check the imported records first?
A checklist to print
- Engagement letters with more than one signer
- An organizer the client can see, on each return it is attached to
- Phone uploads and photos, no app to install
- Reusable request checklists with due dates
- W-2s and 1099s read, values confirmed by a person
- Our own stages, with review notes
- Client approves the draft return online
- E-file status recorded and shown to the client
- A daily list per preparer and a weekly risk email
- Per-season costs known before January
Request access to Firmary
Leave your work email and we’ll email you the next step.
Sources
Each product fact on this page links to a numbered source. Quotes are copied as the page’s text reads on the date shown, spacing included.
- 1
Liscio
You can send organizers and deliveries any time without a bundle. Each one is $7.
- 2
TaxDome
Clients beyond 150 are priced in volume bands, from $15 each on their own down to $5 each in the largest band. ... 400 active clients: $4,125 per year ($0.86 per client a month)
- 3
Soraban
Log In Request a Demo